There were 2 essays on Hope in the last issue of Philosophy Now (Issue 176, October/November 2026); both of them referencing Ernst Bloch (1885-1977), who apparently wrote on this topic extensively. I confess, I haven’t read anything by Bloch. To provide some context, Bloch fled Nazi Germany, so he had firsthand experience of a time when hope was in desperate need by a large number of people, including family and friends, as well as himself, one suspects.
One of the essays, titled In Defence of Hope, was by Sam Nuttall, who ‘studied Philosophy at Newcastle University, where he developed a keen interest in post-Kantian European philosophy’. He also references French philosopher, Gabriel Marcel (1189-1973). I haven’t read anything of Marcel's either, but according to Nuttall, he wanted to ‘sever the ties between hope and optimism’. At one point, Nuttall makes the distinction between ‘willful’ and ‘wistful’ thinking, which reminded me of Arnold Hutschnecker’s distinction between ‘active hope’ and ‘passive hope’ (his coinage) in his book, titled Hope, which I actually have read.
From my experience, optimism is part of the human condition, which I witnessed extensively on engineering projects, most of which, went over time and over budget. It’s human nature for us to underestimate the degree-of-difficulty of a task, especially when it’s going to take a lot of our time, effort and emotional investment. I worked as a project planner, and I would tell people that my job was to be the pessimist, because I was the one person who would attempt to make realistic forecasts. I learned that the underestimation of the degree-of-difficulty was the prime cause of overruns, if not outright failure, on most engineering projects.
I would argue that hope is existential in a way that optimism isn’t, which leads me to the second essay, titled rather provocatively, Fraudulent Hope, by Alice Figes. She is ‘a PhD student in the faculty of POLIS at the University of Cambridge’. Her essay is longer and more thought-provoking in my view, and she discusses Bloch exclusively.
By existential, I mean that hope is something we can’t live without. Even animals have been known to self-harm when hope is effectively eliminated. We tend not to consider that sentient creatures can suffer from the same types of psychological stresses we can, simply because they can’t analyse a situation the way we do. Nevertheless, hope plays a role for all creatures, even though they don’t have a name or even a concept for it. An animal hunting prey ‘hopes’ it will catch it, and the animal being hunted ‘hopes’ it will escape. So, arguably, hope has evolutionary origins.
Eliminating hope in the form of imprisonment is a punishment as old as history. We do it in Australia to asylum seekers, including children, which has serious, longterm mental-health consequences. People have gone on hunger strikes, sown their lips together and performed other forms of self-harm. If you treat people like animals, then you shouldn’t be surprised if they start displaying the same behaviours.
This is a separate issue to the one Figes raises in her essay: essentially about hope as an illusion. Apparently, Bloch cited an alternative version to Homer’s tale of Helen of Troy, where she never goes to Troy at all, but is ‘spirited to Egypt, where she sat out the entire war in peace and relative uneventfulness’ (to quote Figes). This (older) version ‘is preserved in fragments by the lyric poet Stesichorus, dramatized by Euripides in his play, Helen, of 412 BC, and later adopted by Strauss in his 1928 opera.’
The aspect of this which is relevant to ‘fraudulent hope’, is that ‘The goddess Hera, humiliated when Paris chose Aphrodite over her in a divine beauty contest, played a trick on these mere humans, fashioning out of cloud an image of Helen with the appearance of substance but nothing behind it – an eidolon.’
Figes uses the word ‘eidolon’ more generically to represent the false hope that many of us have been deceived by, and even cultivate against our own best interests. She points out how politicians, on occasion, foster this type of hope, a ‘utopian image’ being the phrase she uses, where a future is offered that will satisfy all your material needs, often by demonising a group who are ostensibly stealing your hopes and dreams. Arguably, the worst war in history, still less than a century old, was no less waged for an ideal or eidolon than the fictional war of Troy was.
Paradoxically, both Germany and Japan have prospered in a way unimaginable at that time, by adopting another type of hope. Figes would call it ‘educated hope’, and, according to her, Bloch called it ‘concrete hope’. Basically, Bloch argues for a bottom-up form of hope, rather than top-down (whether it comes from Hera or a self-appointed, authoritarian figure). To quote Figes, paraphrasing Bloch, ‘It can be cultivated by human beings working together to repair, improve, and extend the institutions that already half-belong to them.’ Basically, this is an argument for democracy, which, as Figes points out, is ‘the political form of hope itself.’
But there are other forms of what I’d call ‘negative hope’, when one endures a toxic relationship, for example, because we pursue an ideal that doesn’t exist. One can see a correspondence to Sartre’s idea of ‘bad faith’ (mauvais fois), whereby one follows a role in life that is unsatisfactory, but has been imposed by external forces, or societal expectations. I’m not being judgemental, having been there myself.
I’ve noticed a change in perspective as I’ve got older, whereby I judge life differently, including my own role in it. I’m less harsh on myself, value friendships more and am generally less concerned about society’s expectations concerning success and failure.
I’ve explored the role of hope in my fiction, though not intentionally. I don’t write a story with a theme in mind; I find they appear of their own accord. I’ve had a character literally exhaust all hope, yet survive, but only because others didn’t forget her. I’ve also put a character through an extreme prison environment. He survives by forming friendships and finding a purpose. Yet again, his eventual release is created by others who love him and don’t abandon him, even though he has no knowledge of that. It was only when he returns, that I found similarities in his disposition to my father’s.
My father survived 2.5 years in a German prison camp, and suffered serious PTSD on his return – we were all affected. A couple of things: he never blamed his captors; he argued they were as much a victim as he was. If you’d met my father, you wouldn’t have thought he could be that generous. The other thing is that he escaped 3 times, which tells me he never lost hope.